The rivalry between German engineering and American power is legendary, and with each new generation of cars, the stakes rise. In this latest showdown, Carwow pits the previous generation BMW M4 CS (F82) against the Shelby Mustang GT350. Both are power-packed rear-wheel drive machines that bring their own unique charm to the table. But which one comes out on top? Let’s dive into the stats, performance and results.
BMW M4 CS (F82)
The BMW M4 CS is a showcase of German precision and power refinement. Under the hood is a 3.0-liter twin-turbocharged six-cylinder (S55), producing an impressive 460 hp and 600 Nm (442 lb-ft) of torque. This power is sent exclusively to the rear wheels through a 7-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission, delivering smooth shifts and optimal performance. With a weight of 1,580 kg (3,483 lb), the M4 CS benefits from a favorable weight-to-power ratio, allowing it to maximize agility and straight-line speed.
Shelby Mustang GT350
The Shelby Mustang GT350 brings a different flavor to the table, offering pure American muscle with a high-revving 5.2-liter V8 known as the “Voodoo.” This engine delivers an impressive 600 hp and 597 Nm (441 lb-ft) of torque, providing the perfect combination of power and sound. Unlike the BMW, the GT350 gives the driver full control through a 6-speed manual transmission that emphasizes engagement more than full speed. However, its larger engine and heavier construction contribute to a curb weight of 1,680 kg (3,704 lb), making it less nimble than its German rival.
Drag racing
The F82 M4 CS takes advantage of its lighter weight and turbocharged torque to push forward decisively, crossing the quarter-mile finish line in 12.3 seconds, compared to the GT350’s 12.5 seconds. In the second race, the F82 M4 CS won again. Finally, with launch control out of the equation, the Mustang regains some ground. The race is much closer this time, but the M4 CS still edges out the GT350.
The F82 BMW M4 CS stands out as the overall winner, thanks to its light weight, turbocharger and consistent performance, giving it the edge in most categories. However, the Shelby GT350 is not without its advantages. The naturally aspirated V8 engine and manual transmission provide the first-rate, engaging driving experience that enthusiasts crave.